The Renewable Illusion: Why Fossil Fuels Keep Winning

https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier/2025/08/01/the-renewable-illusion-why-fossil-fuels-keep-winning/

By Robert Rapier, Senior Contributor & Chemical Engineer

Excerpt:

In recent years, many optimistic narratives have overstated the impact of renewables on fossil fuel consumption. The reality is more sobering: renewables are not displacing fossil fuels—especially in non-OECD countries and energy-intensive sectors. They’re growing fast, but they’re still playing catch-up with rising global energy demand.

That is a key takeaway from the 2025 Statistical Review of World Energy. Yes, renewable energy posted impressive gains in 2024. But it still wasn’t enough to bend the curve on global fossil fuel use or carbon emissions.

In 2023, global energy consumption totaled 580 exajoules (EJ), with renewables providing just 29.97 EJ—or 5.2% of the total. By 2024, renewables increased to 32.74 EJ, yet only nudged their global share to 5.5%.

Of the 11.9 EJ growth in total energy demand from 2023 to 2024, renewables supplied just 2.7 EJ—about 23% of the total. Most of the rest came from fossil fuels, with natural gas leading the way at 4.1 EJ. That’s why carbon emissions continued rising in 2024, despite the record-breaking year for renewables.

 

There were some bright spots. In 2024, countries like Argentina, the Netherlands, Poland, New Zealand, the Czech Republic, the UK, and Japan saw renewable energy growth outpace that of fossil fuels. In the United States, renewables met approximately 67% of the year’s increase in energy demand—better than the global average, but still short of closing the gap without additional fossil fuel use.

 

Countries like China and India continue to drive much of the world’s coal and gas consumption, reinforcing their reliance on carbon-intensive fuels. The result is a structural paradox: renewables are accelerating, but not fast enough to displace fossil fuels. Instead, they’re merely supplementing growing demand—allowing carbon emissions to remain on an upward trajectory.

Solar Power: From Niche to Powerhouse
One bright spot is the meteoric rise of solar power. In 2024, global solar generation reached a new record of 7.7 EJ, up 27.5% year-over-year. Over the past decade, solar output has grown at a compound annual rate of 25.8%—the fastest of any major energy source.

Non-OECD countries accounted for 57% of all solar electricity last year. China alone produced 3.0 EJ, nearly 40% of the global total. India’s solar output jumped from just 0.02 EJ in 2014 to 0.5 EJ in 2024—a 23-fold increase fueled by government-backed rooftop programs and grid expansion.

 

Conclusion: Energy Transition Meets Demand Reality
The data makes one thing clear: renewable energy is no longer niche. But it is still not transformative—at least not yet.

The world’s energy transition is being outpaced by growth in total energy demand. Solar is rising faster than wind. Non-OECD countries are leapfrogging traditional leaders. Hydropower is fading into the background. And fossil fuels continue to dominate the global energy mix.

There are reasons for optimism. Costs keep falling. Innovation continues. And emerging markets are proving they can scale renewables quickly. But for the foreseeable future, renewables will remain in an uphill race against ever-rising demand.

Share: