Watch Now! CNN Debate: Climate Depot’s Morano Debates Global Warming – With Full Transcript
December 3, 2009 – ‘CNN Newsroom’
Watch Full Video here.
CNN Host RICK SANCHEZ: One side says the planet is heating up, it’s mostly our fault, and there’s plenty of proof and we’re in big trouble. The other side says nonsense. If we’re warming up, it’s a natural thing, and anyone who believes otherwise is playing with the data for- what, political reasons?
Let me show you something. It’s a very cool piece of video- roll it, if you could, Rog? That’s a glacier right there. It’s in Alaska. It’s the Columbia Glacier. You’re looking at two years of pictures, squished down to show you how this mountain of ice moves, ebbs, and flows. The scientist who made this video and lots more say[s]- look, this is evidence that glacial ice is going away- and not just going away, it’s always gone away- but it’s going away way too fast. He says it is shocking, that this is an emergency.
And here he is to tell you that for himself. That’s James Balog. But wait, I’ve got the other side, as I mentioned, as well- the side who says, nonsense. That’s Marc Morano from ClimateDepot.com, and wait until you hear how fired up he is, especially now that there’s been a pile of e-mails floating around that some say is lending weight to [the] ‘climate denials’ movement.
SANCHEZ: James, let me start with you. I saw the video. I was impressed. It worries the average person to think that that much ice is going into the water and it could possibly make the waters all over the world rise. Convince me that’s the truth.
JAMES BALOG, DIRECTOR, EXTREME ICE SURVEY: Yeah. You know, Rick, I was a climate change skeptic once. When I saw the evidence that was in the ice, I saw the short-term evidence that we were recording and understood how that was embedded in a very, very, very long-term scientific record collected by thousands of very hard working, very cautious, very skeptical scientists from all over the world for decades. Then I realized that we had an issue here. This is not a fiction.
SANCHEZ: James- all right, James, you think he’s wrong? I’m sorry. Marc, you think he’s wrong?
MARC MORANO, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, CLIMATEDEPOT.COM: Well, yeah. I mean, certainly, you can go out and photograph some glaciers and say they’re melting. Was James photographing the size of one and a half Texas increase in Arctic sea ice since 2007 this summer? Was James photographing the Antarctic sea ice record highest sea level in the summer- sea ice cover in the summer this past [Antarctic] summer. Where were James’s cameras then?
SANCHEZ: All right, let’s stop there- let’s stop there. You just raised two questions. Let him answer it. Go ahead, James.
BALOG: These are terrific points. There are obviously natural short-term variations in these cycles. The long term that is- you know, the two, four, six, eight, 10, 20, 100-year trends are very, very clear, and that’s what the denialists like to focus on. We have [unintelligible]-
SANCHEZ: All right, tell me about something. [unintelligible] I’m just going to stop for a minute, because I want our viewers to just not hear two guys going back and forth. I want them to get some evidence here they can put their heads around.
SANCHEZ: I was reading your material, James, for example, and it said in 1997, 1995, 2003, 2004- I think 2006, correct me if I’m wrong, were like the hottest years on record. Is that true? Is that accepted? Can we say we know that for sure or not?
BALOG: Absolutely, that’s correct-
MORANO: You cannot-
BALOG: And we also have very- we have very clear numerical information recorded all around the world by many, many, many, many people-
SANCHEZ: All right, so let me go back to Marc. Let me go back to Marc.
BALOG: Measuring a one-point- excuse me.
SANCHEZ: Go ahead.
BALOG: A 1.3 degree warming trend over the past 100 years. This is real. This is consequential.
SANCHEZ: Okay. Those are quantified numbers, Marc, and that’s important in this conversation. How do you refute that?
MORANO: Sure, but- we’re coming out of the Little Ice Age, which ended around 1850. So, of course, we’ve warmed. But to say it’s the hottest on record, you’re only going back to temperature records 1870, 1880, and you have a lot of biased warmings in there. A lot of the temperature sensors (thermometers) – they’re near concrete, near air conditioners. There’s people actually documenting all the bias. If you look at the satellite data, we actually have had no significant warming since 1998. Actually, no warming- we’ve been cooling in recent years. The entire scare is based on climate models. It’s the climate models.
SANCHEZ: Why would the [unintelligible]- I’m interested- I just don’t want to run out of time- I’m interested in your word, ‘bias.’ Why would people want to make up a story like this? To what end?
MORANO: Biased thermometers-
SANCHEZ: The thermometers are biased?
MORANO: Biased thermometers- they’re placed- yes, they’re placed near air conditioner outlets. They’re placed in hot asphalt-
SANCHEZ: I see-
MORANO: And that’s one of the ways they get this. But again, we’re only talking 120 years. We’re in the coldest period of the Earth’s history geologically. In other words, 90% of the Earth’s history has been warmer than today. We haven’t be able to support ice on either pole. So for James-
SANCHEZ: We’re down to 30 seconds- we’re down to 30 seconds before we go to Wolf [Blitzer], and then we’ll continue. So let me stop you, Marc, for a minute, and then we’ll continue on CNN.com. Answer that- you’ve got 30 seconds, James.
BALOG: With all due respect, this is absurd. This is not the coldest period. This is a distinctly warm period-
MORANO: Geologically speaking –
BALOG: We have a very clear record of climate history going back nearly a million years. We are clearly in a cycle where nature is not natural anymore. The evidence shows that with great precision.
SANCHEZ: All right. Let me stop you both there.
MORANO: That’s not the case.
Watch Full Video of CNN Segment here:
Climate Depot Arctic Fact Sheet – Get the latest peer-reviewed studies and analyses
Antarctic Factsheet on latest peer-reviewed studies and analyses
Flashback: Morano debates former Clinton Official Romm – April 6, 2009
Flashback 2006: Morano Debates IPCC’s Chairman Pachauri at UN Climate Conference in Kenya – ‘Global warming skeptics are ‘demonized’
Great Non-Debate: Wash Post’s Freedman claims paper is not ‘politically motivated’ – Morano in hostile climate debate with TV reporter – Sept. 15, 2009
Video of 2006 climate debate with Revkin, Morano & Blakemore
Flashback 2006: Morano debates ABC’s Bill Blakemore and NYT’s Revkin on global warming
‘Wash. Post’s Andrew Freedman has chickened out on an actual debate with Morano’ – ‘Climate Depot continues to beat WaPo’s Freedman like a rented mule’
Scientific Smackdown: Skeptics Voted The Clear Winners Against Global Warming Believers in Heated NYC Debate – March 16, 2007
Lord Monckton Declared Victor in Global Warming Debate – By His Opponent! – August 19, 2008
Morano Debates Air America’s Hartmann – 2008
Climate Debate: Morano vs. Air America’s Tom Hartmann on Global Warming ‘Solutions’ – February 28, 2009
Debate Over Whether ‘Global Warming is a Global Crisis’ – March 6, 2009