WALTER RUSSELL MEAD: ‘Is Keystone the Biggest Green Defeat Ever?’
'The green movement will have been soundly defeated not by special interests or some perverse capitalist desire to desecrate the earth, but by a very simple set of facts.'
By: Marc Morano - Climate DepotFebruary 3, 2014 6:43 PM
http://www.the-american-interest.com/blog/2014/02/03/is-keystone-the-biggest-green-defeat-ever/
The American Interest
ANALYSIS BY WALTER RUSSELL MEAD & STAFF
ENVIRO-MENTAL
Is Keystone the Biggest Green Defeat Ever?
The long-awaited State Department report on Keystone XL was released last Friday, and it confirmed what common sense already told us: building this pipeline won’t significantly affect emissions. The oil in Canada’s tar sands will make its way to market one way or another—whether by rail, truck, or some other pipeline. Given that, whether or not Keystone is built will have no bearing on the thing environmentalists are so upset about here, which is the actual extraction and consumption of the heavy Albertan crude.
This wasn’t a surprise decision. In fact, it was a confirmation of an earlier draft report that sketched a very similar picture. Michael Levi calls this final version a “stress test” of that earlier report. He further notes that for Keystone to make or break tar sands production would require an incredibly specific set of circumstances: the price of oil would need to hover above the breakeven price for tar sands production but below the price at which producers could profitably bring crude to market by rail or truck. So if President Obama intends to nix the project on green grounds, “he’ll need to thread a very small needle.”
In a speech on climate change this past June, Obama said he would permit Keystone “only if this project does not significantly exacerbate the problem of carbon pollution.” This latest report shows that the pipeline passes that test, and not only that—it’s the greenest option we have in this situation. Scientific American reports:
[T]he State Department finds in the new assessment that the proposed Keystone XL pipeline is the most environmentally friendly option compared to other transportation alternatives, such as railroads and tanker ships. Despite the significant (and unique, due to the oil’s characteristics) risk of spills, a pipeline like Keystone XL is a safer, cheaper and more environmentally benign way of transporting oil, the assessment concludes.
For greens, this should be a gut check—though already we’re seeing that it isn’t. Erich Pich, president of Friends of the Earth, called the report a “farce,” saying that ”the oil industry…had a direct pipeline into the agency” and the findings were a result of “collusion between the State Department, oil industry and the Canadian government.” But the hard truth here is that when Obama approves Keystone—and he now has every reason to do so—the green movement will have been soundly defeated not by special interests or some perverse capitalist desire to desecrate the earth, but by a very simple set of facts.
The New York Times, perhaps seeing this coming, tried to argue last week that the environmentalists’ mobilization against Keystone has been a boon to the movement, regardless of the end outcome. But whatever machinery greens may have built up over the last few years, you can be sure that the same strategic incompetence that permeates the movement will be brought to bear on whatever unicorn hunt they turn to next. The environmental movement desperately needs leadership with at least an iota of understanding of how the world works.
Published on February 3, 2014 3:35 pm
Recent Articles
- Aussie ‘Ambassador for Women’ claims ‘climate change’ causes rape! ‘Exacerbates the risks of sexual & gender-based violence’
- Shellenberger: Yes, You CAN Blame Biden For High Energy Prices
- Kerry vows US will meet climate goals despite Supreme Court setback
- Biden admin’s EPA seeking to close down biggest oil field in U.S. ( & the world), which produces 303,000 barrels of oil a day
- Listen: Morano on Joe Piscopo radio talking SCOTUS climate ruling & how Biden admin seeks ‘a weakened America to be collapsed & rebuilt in the globalist image w/ massive Chinese influence’
- Watch: Biden Economic Adviser on how to explain High Gas Prices to families: ‘This is about the future of the Liberal World Order and we have to stand firm’
- MSNBC: Supreme Court is ‘now a threat to the planet’ – ABC News: ‘Who is going to save the planet?’ – Dems & media melt down over high court’s EPA decision
- Biden: ‘The reason why gas prices are up is because of Russia, Russia Russia, Russia’ – Blames ‘food crisis’ on Russia too
- Aussie Climate Minister Promises to Legislate Away that Evil CO2
- Climate Activist Prof. Dessler seeks to eliminate record-breaking 1930s EPA heatwave chart
- Supreme Court issues pro-science & democracy ruling on CO2: Morano: ‘One small step for climate sanity, one giant leap for democracy’
- SCOTUS Reins in the Power of the EPA
- ‘EPA loses – America Wins’: Supreme Court rules against overreach by EPA
- It’s Official: Supreme Court reins in EPA on Clean Power Plan!
- Media’s claim that Lake Mead is shrinking due to ‘climate change’ DEBUNKED
- Flashback 2007: Inhofe Spokesman Morano: ‘CO2 is not an air pollutant and should not be treated as one’
- All Eyes on SCOTUS: Supreme Court to Issue Climate Endangerment Finding Ruling – To Decide if EPA has authority to regulate CO2 or Congress
- IEA: Europe Will Have To Cut Gas Usage By Nearly One-Third – Germany warns ‘gas is a scarce asset’
- We’re saved! Biden’s Interior Dept Planning to Phase Out Single-Use Plastic on Federal Lands by 2032
- Lab-Grown Meat: Investors Love It, But Scientists Question Safety