Steve McIntyre on Mann’s inquiry: ‘I do expect is that the authors not make untrue statements that can be easily disproven’
'What does Donald Kennedy know about the matter? (North & Kennedy) hardly constitute “looking at issues from all sides”...They did not make the slightest effort to talk to any critic or even neutral observer' -- The “trick” is not a “legitimate” statistical method; its essence is the failure to show adverse data'
