U.S. Government Scientist: 'I disagree strongly with the hurricane-related conclusions of this report!'  

Tuesday, June 16, 2009By Marc Morano  –  Climate Depot

U.S Government Atmospheric Scientist Stanley B. Goldenberg of the Hurricane Research Division of NOAA told Climate Depot his reaction to President Obama's new climate report on June 16, 2009. (See: Obama issues global warming report -- 'Detailed picture of the worst case scenarios' -- 'Poised for its most forceful confrontation with American public' ) Goldenberg is expressing his personal views on the report, not those of any organization. (Full Goldenberg bio available here.)

Goldenberg: I saw the news story on this and looked up the report. I have a pretty good grasp of the hurricane and AGW issues. I have skimmed over the hurricane findings (by the way --- I didn't notice a single recognized hurricane climate expert in the list of authors) and they definitely ignore a large body of the published hurricane research. There are a number of hurricane climate experts (including myself) that would disagree strongly with the hurricane-related conclusions of this report!

The report states (among other things) that:

The power and frequency of Atlantic hurricanes have increased substantially in recent decades.

The number of North American mainland landfalling hurricanes does not appear to have increased over the past century.

Though it is nice that they admit landfall frequency has not increased (happens to be the most reliable long-term Atlantic hurricane statistic) they state as "fact" flawed results that the power and frequency of Atlantic hurricanes have increased.

I can only imagine how slanted the other portions of the report might be as well.

Regards,
Stan

Related Articles:

'Scaremongering': Scientists Pan Obama Climate Report: 'This is not a work of science but an embarrassing episode for the authors and NOAA'...'Misrepresents the science' - June 16, 2009

Add to Newsvine Add to Facebook Add to Digg Add to Twitter Add to DeliciousAdd to PropellerAdd to TechnoratiAdd to StumbleUponAdd to BlinklistAdd to FarkAdd to Reddit
Comments 0 Print    Filed under: hurricanes, science
Get updates by email
  1. AP: Outside science academies to review 'beleaguered' UN IPCC warming panel
  2. Former Apartheid Spy Appointed to Head UN Climate Change Effort
  3. Scientist on 'the Logarithmic Effect of CO2: 'First 20 ppm accounts for over half of heating effect to the pre-industrial level of 280 ppm, by which time CO2 is tuckered out as a ghg'
  4. Mother Jones asking right question: 'Was Waxman-Markey Climate Bill A Waste of Energy?' -- 'Lawmakers who sweated over House cap-and-trade bill aren't happy'
  5. Blame Bart Simpson? EPA chief blames Simpson's cartoon's 'hurtful portrayal' for agency's poor image -- EPA is losing a public relations war over climate regulations
  6. UK greenie George Monbiot despairs of the AGW cause – 'There goes my life's work'
  7. NYT: 'On the Causes of Climate Deadlock': Prof. Yulsman Issues Warning: 'Any scientist who thinks he or she can beat Morano at his own game is in for a very rude awakening'
  8. Financial Times cites Climate Depot's Morano: 'No one believes the warming scientists as they have overreached themselves...It became a silly game where they were trying to scare people'
  9. Climate Depot in Chicago Tribune: 'Climate change skepticism a litmus test for GOP' Morano: 'The new political expediency is to be a global warming skeptic'
  10. Faith-Based Climate Astrology: Women hit by global warming head to Capitol Hill: 'We have freezing temps when we shouldn't have freezing temps'
  11. Released Emails Show Wind Lobby, Soros Group Helped with White House PR
  12. Gore's climate groups unite as he sees 'massive' opposition: 'There has been a very large, organized campaign to try to convince people that global warming is not real'
  13. Randy Olson Dissects Climate Depot's Morano: 'ANALYSIS: WHY MARC MORANO IS SUCH A GOOD COMMUNICATOR'
  14. More Woes: UN IPCC reviewers pointed out wildfire mistake, ignored by authors
  15. As the global warming movement falters, Al Gore's dying Climate Project is folded into The Alliance for Climate Protection
  1. Flashback April 2009: Democrats Refuse to Allow Skeptic to Testify Alongside Gore At Congressional Hearing
  2. Flashback: Gore: U.S. Climate Bill Will Help Bring About 'Global Governance'
  3. Read All About it! Climate Depot Exclusive - Continuously Updated 'ClimateGate' News Round Up
  4. Watch Now: Climate Depot's Morano on Fox News talking Climategate, UN and latest science
  5. Sec. Chu's assertions 'quite simply being proven wrong by the latest climate data'
  6. 'Execute' Skeptics! Shock Call To Action: 'At what point do we jail or execute global warming deniers' -- 'Shouldn't we start punishing them now?'
  7. Climate Depot Aims To Redefine Global Warming Reporting
  8. Earth's 'Fever' Breaks! Global temperatures 'have plunged .74°F since Gore released An Inconvenient Truth'
  9. Climate Depot Banned in Louisiana! State official sought to 'shut down' climate skeptic's testimony at hearing
  10. Scientist Schneider who boasted he could 'slaughter' skeptics in debate backs off...'I certainly will not schedule some political show debate in front of a non-scientific audience'
  11. Video/Transcript: The O'Reilly Factor features Climate Depot on Gore's path to become the first 'Carbon Billionaire'
  12. Updated: Climate Depot Editorial: Climate bill offers (costly) non-solutions to problems that don't even exist
  13. 'Scaremongering': Scientists Pan Obama Climate Report: 'This is not a work of science but an embarrassing episode for the authors and NOAA'...'Misrepresents the science'
  14. Peer-Reviewed Study Rocks Climate Debate! 'Nature not man responsible for recent global warming...little or none of late 20th century warming and cooling can be attributed to humans'
  15. Scientists Write Open Letter to Congress: 'You Are Being Deceived About Global Warming' -- 'Earth has been cooling for ten years'
  1. Flashback April 2009: Democrats Refuse to Allow Skeptic to Testify Alongside Gore At Congressional Hearing
  2. Flashback: Gore: U.S. Climate Bill Will Help Bring About 'Global Governance'
  3. Read All About it! Climate Depot Exclusive - Continuously Updated 'ClimateGate' News Round Up
  4. Watch Now: Climate Depot's Morano on Fox News talking Climategate, UN and latest science
  5. Sec. Chu's assertions 'quite simply being proven wrong by the latest climate data'
  6. 'Execute' Skeptics! Shock Call To Action: 'At what point do we jail or execute global warming deniers' -- 'Shouldn't we start punishing them now?'
  7. Climate Depot Aims To Redefine Global Warming Reporting
  8. Earth's 'Fever' Breaks! Global temperatures 'have plunged .74°F since Gore released An Inconvenient Truth'
  9. Climate Depot Banned in Louisiana! State official sought to 'shut down' climate skeptic's testimony at hearing
  10. Scientist Schneider who boasted he could 'slaughter' skeptics in debate backs off...'I certainly will not schedule some political show debate in front of a non-scientific audience'
  11. Video/Transcript: The O'Reilly Factor features Climate Depot on Gore's path to become the first 'Carbon Billionaire'
  12. Updated: Climate Depot Editorial: Climate bill offers (costly) non-solutions to problems that don't even exist
  13. 'Scaremongering': Scientists Pan Obama Climate Report: 'This is not a work of science but an embarrassing episode for the authors and NOAA'...'Misrepresents the science'
  14. Peer-Reviewed Study Rocks Climate Debate! 'Nature not man responsible for recent global warming...little or none of late 20th century warming and cooling can be attributed to humans'
  15. Scientists Write Open Letter to Congress: 'You Are Being Deceived About Global Warming' -- 'Earth has been cooling for ten years'