Breaking: NOAA, NASA quietly conceded: 2014 was probably not the warmest year on record
Former Harvard Physicist Dr. Lubos Motl: 'According to NOAA, the probability that a different year than 2014 was the warmest one was 52%.
According to NASA, the probability that a different year than 2014 was the warmest one was 62%.'
It is more likely than not that the warmest year was a different one than 2014.
'As the tweet unambiguously proves, NASA's Gavin Schmidt knew about this fact. That didn't prevent them from pushing virtually all mainstream media to publish the lie – in the very title – that:
NASA: 2014 was the warmest year'
Special to Climate Depot
NOAA, NASA: 2014 was probably not the warmest year on our record
By Physicist Dr. Lubos Motl
NOAA, NASA: 2014 was probably not the warmest year on our record
A direct proof that the professional alarmists are intentionally lying
As I discussed in detail, the surface temperature record significantly disagrees with the satellite datasets when it comes to the question whether 2014 was a warmest or nearwarmest year.
Satellites answer this question with a clear “No”: 1998 was 0.3 °C warmer than 2014. This difference (decrease of temperature) is rather safely greater than their error margin which allows you to say that the global mean temperature as defined and calculated via the RSS methodology, for example, almost certainly didn’t peak in 2014. (If it did, it would be no big deal, anyway, but it did not.) The year 2014 was tied on the 6th and 7th place among the 36 according to the RSS AMSU satellite methodology, for example.
On the other hand, NOAA’s NCDC and NASA’s GISS ended up with the mean value of the global mean temperature for 2014 to be about 0.02 °C higher than the second warmest year on their record, with their (different) definition of the global mean temperature, and the second year on their record is 2010 (closely followed by 2005).
Immediately, sensible people – including several climate scientists – were telling them that this difference – 0.02 °C – is so tiny that it is easily beaten by the error margin which prevents you from acquiring any confidence while deciding which year was actually *the* warmest one.
Now, the two questions are: how much do the error margins of the NOAA, NASA temperature records matter? And if they change the answer to the question whether 2014 was the warmest one, did they know about this fact when they loudly announced that “2014 was the warmest year” or did they overlook that detail?
The answer is that the answer is heavily affected by the error margins and NASA, NOAA knew that – but were careful to get the wrong answer to the media. Here is a January 16th, 2015 tweet by Gavin Schmidt of NASA’s GISS, pretty much the most important guy in that agency. He reveals that they provided the media with fraudulent claims while he seems to be arrogant towards a person who just asked (“@DavidRoseUK Were you on the press call? The uncertainties were directly addressed.”):
When the uncertainties are taken into account, you can’t say which year was the warmest one on the two records. Instead, you may only quantify the probability – by integrating the probabilistic distributions in various ways – that one year or another year was the warmest one. And both NASA, NOAA did this exercise for us – in fact, before they spoke to the media! If you were one of the few people in the world who attended a press conference, you could have heard a “footnote”. But no participant did notice that footnote, partially because most journalists are either dishonest or stupid.
The answer is that 2014 had the highest chance, according to their methodology and (possibily manipulated) raw numbers. But in both cases, the chance was lower than 50%. If I simply subtract the first numbers from 100 percent, the tables above imply that
According to NOAA, the probability that a different year than 2014 was the warmest one was 52%.
According to NASA, the probability that a different year than 2014 was the warmest one was 62%.
Using the informal language for the probability ranges, both teams’ work implies that
It is more likely than not that the warmest year was a different one than 2014.
The temperatures were pretty much constant for a decade or two, so the error margins guarantee that all the warmer years in those decades – and there have been several warmer years like that – had comparable chances of having been the #1.
As the tweet unambiguously proves, Gavin Schmidt knew about this fact. That didn’t prevent them from pushing virtually all mainstream media to publish the lie – in the very title – that
NASA: 2014 was the warmest year
Sorry, but even your own work shows that this probably wasn’t the case and you were deliberately lying to the media – and everyone else – about the results of your work. You are doing it all the time, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and 52 or 53 weeks a year.
The tweet by Gavin Schmidt is a simple example of mass manipulation in action. They publish some of the correct yet inconvenient clarifications at places where almost no one reads – the press conference was attended by a small number of people, Schmidt has a few thousand Twitter followers, almost no one reads the bulk of the IPCC reports etc. – while at the places which matter because millions of people read them, they always post the distortions, oversimplifications, and downright lies.
This combination of strategies allows them to say that they “did release the truth”. However, they are careful that they only speak the truth when almost no one listens.
Update
Hours after this blog post was published, The Daily Mail published a criticism by David Rose with pretty much the same content. It is totally plausible but not certain that he was able to make the same conclusion independently of this TRF blog post.

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

sabretruthtiger

Robert

sabretruthtiger

Robert

Robert

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Denis Ables

sabretruthtiger

sabretruthtiger

Robert

Robert

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Guest

Denis Ables

Amos Batto

sabretruthtiger

Robert

Robert

Chris

Robert

Robert

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

sabretruthtiger

Robert

Will Watson

Chris

Will Watson

Chris

Robert

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Robert

Robert

sabretruthtiger

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Betawelder

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Will Watson

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Betawelder

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert

Robert

Robert


Robert

sabretruthtiger

Robert


Robert

Robert


Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Denis Ables

Robert

Denis Ables

Robert




Robert

BajaDreamer



4TimesAYear

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer





Will Watson

Trenton Hansen

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer




Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables




Denis Ables

Will Watson



Betawelder

Will Watson


jfreed27

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

BajaDreamer

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables




Robert


Robert

Robert


Robert

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer

Will Watson

BajaDreamer





Will Watson

Robert

Peter

Amos Batto

Robert

Will Watson

Robert

Will Watson

Robert

Speichera

Will Watson


Speichera

Will Watson

Salvador_H




Chris

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Will Watson

Denis Ables

Denis Ables

Leonard Schopenhouer

Will Watson

Leonard Schopenhouer

Denis Ables




Denis Ables

Salvador_H

Tom Bates

Tom Bates

Tom Bates


Will Watson

Eric Griffith

Denis Ables

Jeff Dozier

Duke Silver

joe

Knut Holt