Scientist Schneider who boasted he could 'slaughter' skeptics in debate backs off...'I certainly will not schedule some political show debate in front of a non-scientific audience'  

Professor Stephen Schneider of Stanford University, a prominent proponent of man-made global warming fears, appears to be backing off of his boast that he could "slaughter" skeptical scientists in a global warming debate. In a May 24, 2009 interview, Schneider publicly boasted any skeptical scientist would be "slaughtered in public debate" against him.

But after many dissenting scientists happily took up the debate challenge, it now appears Schneider is shying away from any such debate.

"I certainly will not schedule some political show debate in front of a non-scientific audience," Schneider told the San Francisco Examiner in a follow up June 1, 2009 article.

"A presidential like debate format with shallow staccato jibes and no nuanced arguments, no--confusion only in that style. I never do those anymore," Schneider explained.

Former Colorado State Climatologist Dr. Roger Pielke Sr. publicly accepted Schneider's global warming debate challenge just days after it was issued. "I would be glad to debate Dr. Schneider...he represents a narrow perspective on climate science," Pielke Sr. said on May 24, 2009. [Editor's Note: Climate Depot was copied on many emails from scientists writing to Professor Schneider accepting his debate challange and Climate Depot also received numerous notes from many scientists eager to accept Schneider's debate challenge in the past week.]

"If [Climatologist] Roger [Pielke Sr.] wants a debate, he can set one up at the American Meteorological Society meeting or the American Geophysical Union meeting and if dates work I'll be happy to go and will encourage others like Ben Santer or Kevin Trenberth to join in. That I would do," Schneider now asserts.

Schneider explained: "Some of the skeptics are going ballistic over my admittedly too provocative word 'slaughter'--though given the framing I said I believe it would happen. But they misquote me in saying I challenged them to a debate. I challenged them to go to a legitimate scientific meeting with a knowledgeable audience and challenge from the floor with a room full of experts. I think they would be pretty unhappy with the outcome."

Update: Meteorologist Joe D'Aleo weighs in on Schneider's "terms" for a global warming debate.

"In other words, like the sports teams that prefer to play in the friendly confines of their home park than at a hostile away team's stadium, Schneider insists on having the debate at one of the conferences attended by grant toting scientists and thus have a crowd of fellow alarmists to cheer him on and TO MAKE IT A FAIR FIGHT," D'Aleo wrote on his IceCap.Us website on June 2, 2009.

Below is Climate Depot's May 24, 2009 report on Schneider's orginal debate challenge.

Skeptics 'slaughtered'? Global Warming Professor Stephen Schneider boasts he could 'slaughter skeptical scientists in public debate!'

• New
• Popular
• Past 7 days

1. The U.S. Intense Hurricane Drought: 'Record-long stretch of no intense hurricane landfalls still continuing'
2. Climate Depot's Morano: 'Every day now, skeptics are compared to Holocaust deniers & the media yawns' -- MSM Condemns Heartland's Billboard, Ignores What Alarmists Do Everyday
3. Letter to Ed in NYT on Hansen: Consensus?! 'European scientists in the 15th century agreed that the earth was the center of the universe. That didn't make it true'
4. Does NASA's Hansen Ever Look At Actual Data? 'His claims of permanent drought are not consistent with US drought record, which shows a decrease in drought & increase in wetness since 1895'
5. Study: Shopping malls prevent animals from escaping global warming: ' '9% of Western Hemisphere´s mammals are not able to run fast enough in order to flee catastrophic global warming'
6. Arctic seabirds doing fine despite of 'global warming': 'Little auks, the most common seabirds in the Arctic, are adapting their fishing behavior to warming surface waters in the Greenland Sea'
7. Global Warming Predicted Hotspot Over Tropics Is Non-Existent: 'Empirical measurements confirm Hansen's predicted tropical hotspot has not happened, it's a 'coldspot' instead'
8. NASA's Hansen warns of end times! Global warming increasing by 'equivalent to exploding 400,000 Hiroshima atomic bombs per day 365 days per year'
9. Greenie Grist Mag. laments lack of interest in AGW.: 'The most critical issue ever to face humanity is getting less attention this election season than dogs'
10. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
11. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
12. Panel discussion: Ethics, Stanford: A question of balance
13. New paper finds solar activity and natural climate cycles explain rainfall variations over past 160 years
14. New paper finds planetary motions explain climate; predicts stable climate: Study in Journal of Atmospheric & Solar-Terrestrial Physics
15. New paper finds 'no model consensus' on precipitation projections: Journal of Geophysical Research study finds 19 different models had 'no model consensus'

1. The U.S. Intense Hurricane Drought: 'Record-long stretch of no intense hurricane landfalls still continuing'
2. Climate Depot's Morano: 'Every day now, skeptics are compared to Holocaust deniers & the media yawns' -- MSM Condemns Heartland's Billboard, Ignores What Alarmists Do Everyday
3. Letter to Ed in NYT on Hansen: Consensus?! 'European scientists in the 15th century agreed that the earth was the center of the universe. That didn't make it true'
4. Does NASA's Hansen Ever Look At Actual Data? 'His claims of permanent drought are not consistent with US drought record, which shows a decrease in drought & increase in wetness since 1895'
5. Study: Shopping malls prevent animals from escaping global warming: ' '9% of Western Hemisphere´s mammals are not able to run fast enough in order to flee catastrophic global warming'
6. Arctic seabirds doing fine despite of 'global warming': 'Little auks, the most common seabirds in the Arctic, are adapting their fishing behavior to warming surface waters in the Greenland Sea'
7. Global Warming Predicted Hotspot Over Tropics Is Non-Existent: 'Empirical measurements confirm Hansen's predicted tropical hotspot has not happened, it's a 'coldspot' instead'
8. NASA's Hansen warns of end times! Global warming increasing by 'equivalent to exploding 400,000 Hiroshima atomic bombs per day 365 days per year'
9. Greenie Grist Mag. laments lack of interest in AGW.: 'The most critical issue ever to face humanity is getting less attention this election season than dogs'
10. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
11. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
12. Panel discussion: Ethics, Stanford: A question of balance
13. New paper finds solar activity and natural climate cycles explain rainfall variations over past 160 years
14. New paper finds planetary motions explain climate; predicts stable climate: Study in Journal of Atmospheric & Solar-Terrestrial Physics
15. New paper finds 'no model consensus' on precipitation projections: Journal of Geophysical Research study finds 19 different models had 'no model consensus'

1. The U.S. Intense Hurricane Drought: 'Record-long stretch of no intense hurricane landfalls still continuing'
2. Climate Depot's Morano: 'Every day now, skeptics are compared to Holocaust deniers & the media yawns' -- MSM Condemns Heartland's Billboard, Ignores What Alarmists Do Everyday
3. Letter to Ed in NYT on Hansen: Consensus?! 'European scientists in the 15th century agreed that the earth was the center of the universe. That didn't make it true'
4. Does NASA's Hansen Ever Look At Actual Data? 'His claims of permanent drought are not consistent with US drought record, which shows a decrease in drought & increase in wetness since 1895'
5. Study: Shopping malls prevent animals from escaping global warming: ' '9% of Western Hemisphere´s mammals are not able to run fast enough in order to flee catastrophic global warming'
6. Arctic seabirds doing fine despite of 'global warming': 'Little auks, the most common seabirds in the Arctic, are adapting their fishing behavior to warming surface waters in the Greenland Sea'
7. Global Warming Predicted Hotspot Over Tropics Is Non-Existent: 'Empirical measurements confirm Hansen's predicted tropical hotspot has not happened, it's a 'coldspot' instead'
8. NASA's Hansen warns of end times! Global warming increasing by 'equivalent to exploding 400,000 Hiroshima atomic bombs per day 365 days per year'
9. Greenie Grist Mag. laments lack of interest in AGW.: 'The most critical issue ever to face humanity is getting less attention this election season than dogs'
10. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
11. New paper in journal Weather finds large increase in sunshine since the 1980's; dwarfs alleged effect of CO2
12. Panel discussion: Ethics, Stanford: A question of balance
13. New paper finds solar activity and natural climate cycles explain rainfall variations over past 160 years
14. New paper finds planetary motions explain climate; predicts stable climate: Study in Journal of Atmospheric & Solar-Terrestrial Physics
15. New paper finds 'no model consensus' on precipitation projections: Journal of Geophysical Research study finds 19 different models had 'no model consensus'