Journal “Nature Communications” climate blacklist
People with the temerity to correct the record on climate change must be silenced.
That’s the outrageous point of a new study published in the journal Nature Communication.
“The time has arrived for professional journalists and editors to ameliorate the disproportionate attention given to (climate change contrarians) by focusing instead on career experts and relevant calls to action,” the authors said.
While the study’s goal is severely off base, it nonetheless produced two mathematical rankings CFACT is more than a little tickled by.
According to a ranking of how often “contrarians,” as the study labels us, are cited in the media, CFACT’s Marc Morano is far and away the world’s most effective climate communicator.
Marc is number one, with 4,171 media references, nearly double Senator James Inhofe’s 2,628 and Secretary Rick Perry’s 1,903. Marc appeared in many multiples of media references compared to anyone else as you proceed down the rankings.
Steven Hayward of the Powerline Blog wrote, “Morano is truly the Pete Rose and Hank Aaron of climate contrarians.”
[Note: Even warmists weighted in on Morano being ranked Number 1:
Does climate community realize Marc Morano @climatedepot is most prolific voice of skepticism by a looooong way? He has 35% more articles than any others. There should be an Inst for the Study of Morano #ClimateChange #ClimateCommunication #scicomm https://t.co/9WkCfwYX11 pic.twitter.com/sGYuhJEbOJ
— Randy Olson (@ABTagenda) August 14, 2019
2007 I had climate “contrarian” Marc Morano @climatedepot in my movie "Sizzle", 2010 I warned of his media savvy https://t.co/PLGF5y2Nz3, today he is a Fox News regular & most prolific skeptic in this new article: https://t.co/9WkCfwYX11 @Revkin @seeoh2 @JaydeLovell #scicomm
— Randy Olson (@ABTagenda) August 14, 2019
Skeptic Jo Nova comments: “Marc Morano tops the Nature blacklist, and no man deserves it more. Congratulations Marc!”
Newsweek Mag. also reported on the new study and featured Climate Depot prominently.
#
Rucker article continues: The study also ranks our website, CFACT.org, on its list of the top 100 “most prolific media sources” for articles skeptical of the global warming narrative and ranks Climate Depot number 1! See, figure 2b.
The list of 386 people on the climate blacklist reads like an honor roll. Here’s a sample:
- Apollo Astronaut Harrison Schmitt – the only scientist to walk on the moon;
- Apollo Astronaut Walt Cunningham – from the first crew to ride the Saturn V rocket;
- Freeman Dyson – The eminent Princeton physicist who postulated the Dyson sphere;
- Ross McKitrick and Steven McIntyre – the Canadian researchers whose meticulous mathematical audit debunked Michael Mann’s infamous hockey stick graph;
- Anthony Watts – The prominent meteorologist and creator of Watts Up With That;
- Rick Perry – The U.S. Secretary of Energy;
- Judith Curry – A climate scientist with over 130 peer-reviewed papers;
- Roy Spencer and John Christy – Scientists who manage temperature satellites and developed the first successful satellite temperature record;
- Fred Singer – The genius scientist who established the weather satellite network;
- Roger Pielke, Jr. – The professor who showed that extreme weather hasn’t worsened and disaster costs declined;
- Richard Lindzen – The MIT scientist known for his brilliant work on atmospheric physics and author of over 200 papers;
- Will Happer – The Princeton atomic physicist and pioneer in optics;
- Rudy Giuliani – America’s Mayor;
- Mike Pence – Merely the Vice President of the United States (V.P. Gore’s OK?)
While the rankings appear to be genuine in terms of the amount of media individuals garnered, the study’s black and white, unnuanced choice of whom to include on its contrarian list is bush league. It actually used DeSmog Blog as a major source! Its mathematical comparison showing that people who debate climate policy in the public policy arena have greater media exposure than researchers who are cited in academic journals is an apples and oranges comparison, lacking scientific validity, that yields a no-brainer. Their decision to not rank the amount of media garnered by warming campaigners, which would have yielded a useful comparison, reveals this for a bogus and offensive propaganda hit piece.
New Climate Blacklist ranks how often climate skeptics cited in media, but CFACT’s Marc Morano is proudly number 1, w/ 4,171 media hits, double Sen. James Inhofe’s 2,628 & Sec. Rick Perry’s 1,903 @ClimateDepot https://t.co/mFPaUWKEHE
— CFACT (@CFACT) August 18, 2019
We are each exposed to a mountain of media every day. Peruse the headlines and media coverage of climate for yourself. Do you need a mathematical analysis to determine which way the coverage is skewed? Wouldn’t you love to see those hard numbers?
Shame on study authors, Alexander Michael Petersen, Emmanuel M. Vincent, and Anthony LeRoy Westerling.
But, thank you to all our friends and supporters who helped CFACT become the most effective climate communicators in the world.
#
The Study is being trashed for its attempts to blacklist climate skeptics and other reasons.
https://twitter.com/RogerPielkeJr/status/1161684580446814209
The latest travesty in ‘consensus enforcement’ – Climatologist Dr. Judith Curry calls it “the worst paper I have ever seen published in a reputable journal”.
Enlisting peer-reviewed science in the climate crusade
Nature Communications ‘blinks’ over slimy climate blacklist from @UCmerced authors
Skeptics get 49% more media, and other fairy fantasy stories from Nature Gossip Mag
Richard Tol rips the study: ‘The paper is bad’
#
Below is Full list & rankings of ‘the 386 Climate Contrarians” according to the study:
MARC MORANO,4171,0.023255813953488372,1 JAMES INHOFE,2628,0.14421613394216135,2 RICK PERRY,1903,0.11455596426694692,3 JUDITH CURRY,1107,0.12014453477868112,4 ROY SPENCER,892,0.06278026905829596,5 RICHARD LINDZEN,878,0.07517084282460136,6 CHRISTOPHER MONCKTON,868,0.08294930875576037,7 LAMAR SMITH,831,0.07581227436823104,8 BJORN LOMBORG,770,0.09480519480519481,9 JOHN CHRISTY,723,0.1078838174273859,10 WILLIE SOON,711,0.090014064697609,11 ANTHONY WATTS,699,0.09585121602288985,12 ROGER PIELKE JR,697,0.1406025824964132,13 FRED SINGER,626,0.05750798722044728,14 PATRICK MICHAELS,533,0.08067542213883677,15 REX TILLERSON,507,0.11834319526627218,16 BOB CARTER,505,0.05742574257425743,17 DAVID ROSE,437,0.05491990846681922,18 MICHAEL FOX,409,0.019559902200488997,19 STEVE MCINTYRE,374,0.06684491978609626,20 MYRON EBELL,369,0.08672086720867209,21 MARK STEYN,358,0.0446927374301676,22 JAMES TAYLOR,358,0.05307262569832402,23 ROBERT DAVIS,345,0.020289855072463767,24 DAVID DOUGLAS,341,0.011730205278592375,25 KENNETH GREEN,339,0.011799410029498525,26 JAMES DELINGPOLE,339,0.14454277286135694,27 EDWARD DAVID,333,0.02702702702702703,28 TOM HARRIS,319,0.06583072100313479,29 ROBERT BRADLEY,316,0.012658227848101266,30 RICHARD TOL,316,0.11708860759493671,31 HARRISON SCHMITT,315,0.015873015873015872,32 DON EASTERBROOK,311,0.00964630225080386,33 MAURICE NEWMAN,308,0.1331168831168831,34 MIKE PENCE,302,0.1291390728476821,35 GEORGE ALLEN,301,0.016611295681063124,36 MATT RIDLEY,292,0.1952054794520548,37 NIGEL LAWSON,280,0.3392857142857143,38 FREEMAN DYSON,264,0.07196969696969698,39 STEVEN HAYWARD,262,0.003816793893129771,40 ROSS MCKITRICK,252,0.0992063492063492,41 JOHN COLEMAN,252,0.07539682539682539,42 JOHN CHARLES,250,0.036,43 TIM BALL,242,0.024793388429752067,44 MALCOLM ROBERTS,236,0.11864406779661017,45 JOSEPH BAST,234,0.07692307692307693,46 CHRIS HORNER,233,0.0815450643776824,47 DAVID LEGATES,226,0.04424778761061947,48 PATRICK MOORE,218,0.027522935779816515,49 BENNY PEISER,217,0.23963133640552994,50 IAN PLIMER,209,0.11961722488038277,51 CRAIG IDSO,204,0.03431372549019608,52 DAVID KREUTZER,198,0.12121212121212122,53 CHIP KNAPPENBERGER,197,0.08629441624365482,54 ANDREW BOLT,196,0.07142857142857142,55 WILLIAM HAPPER,194,0.09278350515463918,56 DAVID EVANS,175,0.03428571428571429,57 ROGER PIELKE SR,170,0.06470588235294118,58 SCOTT PRUITT,157,0.14012738853503184,59 CHRISTOPHER BOOKER,154,0.2012987012987013,60 SALLIE BALIUNAS,150,0.04666666666666667,61 HENRIK SVENSMARK,150,0.1,62 JOE BASTARDI,146,0.0410958904109589,63 DANA ROHRABACHER,144,0.0763888888888889,64 MARLO LEWIS,142,0.035211267605633804,65 STEVE MILLOY,127,0.047244094488188976,66 STERLING BURNETT,127,0.023622047244094488,67 DAVID WHITEHOUSE,126,0.1746031746031746,68 RONALD BAILEY,123,0.,69 CHRIS DE FREITAS,118,0.05084745762711865,70 MICHAEL KELLY,116,0.08620689655172414,71 WILLIAM KININMONTH,114,0.05263157894736842,72 VACLAV KLAUS,111,0.15315315315315314,73 PAUL DRIESSEN,111,0.02702702702702703,74 DONNA LAFRAMBOISE,102,0.058823529411764705,75 ART ROBINSON,102,0.029411764705882353,76 SCOTT ARMSTRONG,101,0.0297029702970297,77 WILLIAM GRAY,100,0.07,78 ROBERT FERGUSON,100,0.02,79 LARRY BELL,99,0.010101010101010102,80 ROBERT BALLING,97,0.020618556701030927,81 GEORGE TAYLOR,97,0.030927835051546393,82 VINCENT GRAY,95,0.031578947368421054,83 ANDREW MONTFORD,93,0.27956989247311825,84 PIERS CORBYN,91,0.24175824175824176,85 LAWRENCE SOLOMON,90,0.044444444444444446,86 STEVE GOREHAM,86,0.023255813953488372,87 ROBERT MICHAELS,85,0.011764705882352941,88 IVAR GIAEVER,85,0.07058823529411765,89 NIR SHAVIV,83,0.04819277108433735,90 ALEX EPSTEIN,82,0.06097560975609756,91 INDUR GOKLANY,80,0.0375,92 JIM MARTIN,77,0.03896103896103896,93 STEVEN GODDARD,76,0.09210526315789473,94 MADHAV KHANDEKAR,76,0.02631578947368421,95 NICK MINCHIN,75,0.14666666666666667,96 JOHN HINDERAKER,75,0.,97 ROGER HELMER,73,0.2876712328767123,98 JOANNE NOVA,73,0.0273972602739726,99 FRITZ VAHRENHOLT,72,0.027777777777777776,100 CALVIN BEISNER,72,0.05555555555555555,101 TIM PHILLIPS,71,0.08450704225352113,102 JIM SENSENBRENNER,70,0.05714285714285714,103 JENNIFER MAROHASY,70,0.05714285714285714,104 RUDY GIULIANI,69,0.057971014492753624,105 TIMOTHY PATTERSON,66,0.015151515151515152,106 GARTH PALTRIDGE,66,0.,107 SEBASTIAN LUNING,64,0.015625,108 DAVID WOJICK,64,0.078125,109 WILLIAM BRIGGS,61,0.04918032786885246,110 JAN ERIK SOLHEIM,61,0.21311475409836064,111 ROBERT GORDON,59,0.01694915254237288,112 CHRISTOPHER ESSEX,59,0.,113 JACK GERARD,58,0.05172413793103448,114 DENNIS AVERY,57,0.03508771929824561,115 ALAN CARLIN,57,0.05263157894736842,116 PHELIM MCALEER,56,0.03571428571428571,117 DAVID HENDERSON,56,0.03571428571428571,118 RICHARD COURTNEY,55,0.,119 CORY BERNARDI,55,0.12727272727272726,120 ROBERT BRYCE,54,0.12962962962962962,121 NICOLA SCAFETTA,53,0.03773584905660377,122 JOHN STOSSEL,53,0.05660377358490566,123 RUPERT DARWALL,52,0.019230769230769232,124 RON ARNOLD,51,0.0196078431372549,125 WILLIAM ALEXANDER,50,0.,126 JAY LEHR,49,0.02040816326530612,127 ROBERT MENDELSOHN,48,0.020833333333333332,128 KESTEN GREEN,48,0.020833333333333332,129 SHERWOOD IDSO,47,0.,130 RUSSELL COOK,47,0.02127659574468085,131 PAUL CHESSER,47,0.,132 DAVID BELLAMY,47,0.3191489361702128,133 GARY SHARP,46,0.,134 ROGER COHEN,45,0.13333333333333333,135 ROBERT MURPHY,45,0.,136 DAVID ARCHIBALD,44,0.022727272727272728,137 CRAIG RUCKER,44,0.045454545454545456,138 VIV FORBES,43,0.,139 IAN CLARK,43,0.046511627906976744,140 SYUN ICHI AKASOFU,41,0.04878048780487805,141 GEORGE CHRISTENSEN,41,0.14634146341463414,142 FREDERICK SEITZ,40,0.05,143 EDWARD WEGMAN,40,0.175,144 IAIN MURRAY,39,0.05128205128205128,145 WILLIS ESCHENBACH,38,0.05263157894736842,146 WALTER CUNNINGHAM,38,0.,147 ART POPE,37,0.,148 STEWART FRANKS,36,0.,149 SONJA BOEHMER CHRISTIANSEN,36,0.,150 MITCHELL TAYLOR,36,0.,151 CRAIG LOEHLE,36,0.,152 GRAHAM SMITH,35,0.02857142857142857,153 GARY ENGLAND,35,0.05714285714285714,154 ANN MCELHINNEY,35,0.,155 MARITA NOON,34,0.,156 CHRIS LANDSEA,34,0.08823529411764706,157 BENJAMIN ZYCHER,33,0.,158 PAUL REITER,31,0.,159 DAN LEWIS,31,0.0967741935483871,160 SCOTT DENNING,30,0.1,161 LEIGHTON STEWARD,30,0.06666666666666667,162 FRED GOLDBERG,30,0.03333333333333333,163 BRYAN LEYLAND,30,0.,164 ALBERT JACOBS,30,0.,165 RICHARD KEEN,29,0.034482758620689655,166 NILS AXEL MORNER,29,0.,167 ANTHONY LUPO,29,0.,168 JACK BARRETT,28,0.,169 HOWARD HAYDEN,28,0.,170 KIMINORI ITOH,27,0.037037037037037035,171 DAVID SCHNARE,27,0.07407407407407407,172 CLAUDE ALLEGRE,27,0.1111111111111111,173 ART HORN,27,0.,174 SAM KAZMAN,26,0.038461538461538464,175 JOSEPH CLARK,26,0.038461538461538464,176 JOHN DALE DUNN,26,0.,177 GEORGE KUKLA,26,0.038461538461538464,178 BEN LIEBERMAN,26,0.038461538461538464,179 TODD MYERS,25,0.12,180 SUSAN CROCKFORD,25,0.08,181 NIGEL CALDER,25,0.2,182 JULIAN MORRIS,25,0.2,183 GERRIT VAN DER LINGEN,25,0.,184 CLIFF OLLIER,25,0.,185 RAY EVANS,24,0.,186 NORMAN ROGERS,24,0.,187 BURT RUTAN,24,0.08333333333333333,188 BRIAN SUSSMAN,24,0.041666666666666664,189 MIKE NOEL,23,0.043478260869565216,190 LEWIS PAGE,23,0.30434782608695654,191 LEE GERHARD,23,0.,192 DAVID DEMING,23,0.,193 TOM MCCLINTOCK,22,0.,194 JOHN O'SULLIVAN,22,0.045454545454545456,195 TERRY DUNLEAVY,21,0.,196 REID BRYSON,21,0.,197 JOSEPH D'ALEO,21,0.,198 HENDRIK TENNEKES,21,0.047619047619047616,199 TODD WYNN,20,0.,200 PETR CHYLEK,20,0.,201 JAN VEIZER,20,0.,202 HABIBULLO ABDUSSAMATOV,20,0.,203 EIGIL CHRISTENSEN,20,0.05,204 JAMES O'BRIEN,18,0.,205 DAVID TUERCK,18,0.1111111111111111,206 TOM SEGALSTAD,17,0.058823529411764705,207 RODNEY NICHOLS,17,0.17647058823529413,208 JEFF CONDON,17,0.11764705882352941,209 HANS LABOHM,17,0.058823529411764705,210 EZRA LEVANT,17,0.,211 ANDREI ILLARIONOV,17,0.23529411764705882,212 ZBIGNIEW JAWOROWSKI,16,0.,213 LAURENCE GOULD,16,0.,214 JOEL SCHWARTZ,16,0.,215 JAMES MCGRATH,16,0.125,216 DOUGLAS HOYT,16,0.,217 DANIEL SIMMONS,16,0.125,218 PETER FERRARA,15,0.,219 JOHN SHADE,15,0.2,220 JOHN DROZ,15,0.,221 JAN BRESLOW,15,0.26666666666666666,222 GERRIT VAN KOOTEN,15,0.,223 CHARLES BATTIG,15,0.,224 BOB FOSTER,15,0.,225 ANTHONY SADAR,15,0.5333333333333333,226 YURI IZRAEL,14,0.14285714285714285,227 ROY CLARK,14,0.14285714285714285,228 OWEN MCSHANE,14,0.,229 KEN HAAPALA,14,0.,230 GERD RAINER WEBER,14,0.,231 STEVE BANNON,13,0.,232 STANLEY GOLDENBERG,13,0.,233 JEFF KUETER,13,0.15384615384615385,234 DAVID BOWEN,13,0.15384615384615385,235 ROY INNIS,12,0.,236 RALPH ALEXANDER,12,0.08333333333333333,237 PETER DIETZE,12,0.,238 KILEZ MORE,12,0.,239 KEVIN DAYARATNA,12,0.,240 ISAAC ORR,12,0.08333333333333333,241 RICHARD FINK,11,0.,242 KENDRA OKONSKI,11,0.09090909090909091,243 HAROLD DOIRON,11,0.,244 GRAEME SWINDLES,11,0.09090909090909091,245 FRANK CLEMENTE,11,0.,246 DAN GAINOR,11,0.,247 WILLIAM COTTON,10,0.,248 WIBJORN KARLEN,10,0.,249 PAUL COPPER,10,0.,250 MICHAEL LIMBURG,10,0.3,251 GREGG EASTERBROOK,10,0.1,252 BARRY BRILL,10,0.,253 WILLIAM KAY,9,0.1111111111111111,254 VINCENT COURTILLOT,9,0.,255 TAD MURTY,9,0.1111111111111111,256 KEITH IDSO,9,0.,257 JOANNE SIMPSON,9,0.,258 JIM JOHNSTON,9,0.,259 JAMES SPANN,9,0.,260 FERENC MISKOLCZI,9,0.,261 BRIAN VALENTINE,9,0.,262 BOB ARMSTRONG,9,0.,263 WILLEM DE LANGE,8,0.,264 OLAVI KARNER,8,0.,265 KEITH LOCKITCH,8,0.,266 HUGH ELLSAESSER,8,0.,267 FRED MICHEL,8,0.,268 ARTHUR RORSCH,8,0.,269 TOM TANTON,7,0.,270 THOMAS WYSMULLER,7,0.,271 RUSSELL SEITZ,7,0.14285714285714285,272 MIKLOS ZAGONI,7,0.,273 MICHAEL ECONOMIDES,7,0.,274 KEITH HAGE,7,0.,275 JOEL WOOD,7,0.14285714285714285,276 GERALD MARSH,7,0.,277 DONALD RAPP,7,0.,278 BONNER COHEN,7,0.,279 TERRENCE FLOWER,6,0.,280 ROY CORDATO,6,0.,281 ROGER TATTERSALL,6,0.16666666666666666,282 ROBERT ESSENHIGH,6,0.,283 MICK MULVANEY,6,0.,284 MICHAEL JUNGBAUER,6,0.,285 JOHN H SUNUNU,6,0.,286 JAMES PEDEN,6,0.,287 HOWARD MACCABEE,6,0.,288 GABRIEL CALZADA,6,0.,289 DONN DEARS,6,0.,290 CLAES JOHNSON,6,0.,291 ANTONINO ZICHICHI,6,0.,292 VIJAY KUMAR RAINA,5,0.,293 RANDY SIMMONS,5,0.,294 LEON LOUW,5,0.,295 JOHN HUMPHREYS,5,0.2,296 HARRY PRIEM,5,0.,297 GERHARD GERLICH,5,0.,298 FRIEDRICH KARL EWERT,5,0.,299 DENNIS HEDKE,5,0.,300 UTZ TILLMANN,4,0.,301 ROB SCAGEL,4,0.,302 RICHARD RAHN,4,0.25,303 PAUL WAGGONER,4,0.,304 NIGER INNIS,4,0.,305 MIKE CATANZARO,4,0.25,306 MARCUS ERNST,4,0.,307 HELEN ROE,4,0.,308 GEOFFREY DUFFY,4,0.,309 BORIS WINTERHALTER,4,0.,310 ASMUNN MOENE,4,0.,311 VICTOR MANUEL VELASCO HERRERA,3,0.,312 REBEKAH MERCER,3,0.3333333333333333,313 PAMELA GORMAN,3,0.,314 MARY HUTZLER,3,0.,315 JOHN NOTHDURFT,3,0.,316 JOE FONE,3,0.,317 JEROME ARNETT,3,0.,318 JAMES WANLISS,3,0.,319 HENRI MASSON,3,0.,320 FRANCO BATTAGLIA,3,0.,321 EVELYN BROWNING GARRISS,3,0.6666666666666666,322 DOUGLAS LEAHEY,3,0.,323 DOUG DOMENECH,3,0.,324 DAVID PADDEN,3,0.,325 BARUN MITRA,3,0.,326 ARUN AHLUWALIA,3,0.,327 ANDREAS PROKOPH,3,0.,328 AL PEKAREK,3,0.,329 ALEXANDRE AGUIAR,3,0.,330 WOLFGANG MULLER,2,0.,331 WERNER WEBER,2,0.,332 TOMASZ TELUK,2,0.,333 ROGER BEZDEK,2,0.5,334 ROBERT SHOUP,2,0.,335 JOSEF REICHHOLF,2,0.,336 JAMES ENSTROM,2,0.5,337 GORDON SWATERS,2,0.5,338 FRANCISCO CAPELLA,2,0.,339 DONALD BOUDREAUX,2,0.,340 CARLO STAGNARO,2,0.,341 BRUNO WISKEL,2,0.,342 BECKY NORTON DUNLOP,2,0.,343 AUGUST AUER,2,0.,344 ANTON URIARTE,2,0.,345 NATHALIE ELGRABLY LEVY,1,0.,346 MARTIN HOVLAND,1,0.,347 KEN MALLOY,1,0.,348 JOSEPH CONKLIN,1,0.,349 HORST JOACHIM LUDECKE,1,0.,350 HOLGER THUSS,1,0.,351 DON KEILLER,1,0.,352 BRUCE EVERETT,1,0.,353 BO NORDELL,1,0.,354 BETTE GRANDE,1,0.,355 AVRIL TERRI JACKSON,1,0.,356 ARTHUR MIDDLETON HUGHES,1,0.,357 ALISTER MCFARQUHAR,1,0.,358 ALEX FITZSIMMONS,1,0.,359 ALEXANDRA LIDDY BOURNE,1,0.,360 ALAN MOGHISSI,1,0.,361 WALTER FETT,0,0,362 SÖREN FLODERUS,0,0,363 SAMUELE FURFARI,0,0,364 RONALD RYCHLAK,0,0,365 RICHARD TRZUPEK,0,0,366 REYNALD DU BERGER,0,0,367 PAAVO SIITAM,0,0,368 MICHELLE MICHOT FOSS,0,0,369 MICHAEL GOETZ,0,0,370 KLAUS ANGERER,0,0,371 JOHN LOEFFLER,0,0,372 JIM PUPLAVA,0,0,373 JACOB NORDANGARD,0,0,374 HUBBEL RELAT,0,0,375 HELMUT ALT,0,0,376 GUNTER EDERER,0,0,377 GERTRUD HOHLER,0,0,378 GERNOT PATZELT,0,0,379 DOUGLAS SOUTHGATE,0,0,380 DONALD HERTZMARK,0,0,381 DANIEL SUTTER,0,0,382 CARL RIBBING,0,0,383 AUGUSTO MANGINI,0,0,384 ANNE DEBEIL,0,0,385 AARON STOVER,0,0,386 #
Related: